Best email broadcast tools for nonprofits welcoming new supporters
For most small charities, Brevo is the place to build a welcome series without a budget line. Its pricing help page lists a free plan with 300 email sends a day and notes 2,000 contacts in marketing automation, and the Standard plan, which adds automation and A/B testing, starts at $18 a month. A welcome series is automation by definition, so the free allowance matters more here than a pretty editor.
Every way in the door needs its own first email
Nonprofits collect contacts in more ways than a business does: a form on the website, a clipboard at a street event, a volunteer application, a first donation, a petition, a school visit. These people arrived with different expectations, and a single "Welcome to our community!" email speaks to none of them. Pick the three or four doors that bring in the most people and give each a welcome that fits what the person just did.
| How they joined | First email should say | Do not do |
|---|---|---|
| Website newsletter form | What the newsletter covers and how often it comes | Ask for a gift in the same message |
| Volunteer application | The next practical step, a named coordinator and how to reach them | Add them to fundraising mail without asking |
| First donation | A human thank-you for the gift; the receipt comes from the donation platform | Duplicate or replace the receipt |
| Event sign-in sheet | Where the event photos or follow-up will be, and a one-click confirm | Import the sheet before anyone has confirmed |
| Petition or campaign signup | What happens next with their signature and how to stop hearing about it | Convert them into a newsletter subscription silently |
Say what you will send, and ask for one thing
Yahoo's sender guidance asks senders to set expectations at signup: what mail to expect, how often and what it will look like. A welcome email is the second chance to do that if the form was vague. State the frequency in a sentence, tell people that a reply reaches a person, and give the unsubscribe link its normal place. Then ask for one action that is easy and matches why they came: read the latest story, confirm which topics they want, pick a volunteering date. Leave the donation request for a later message unless the person has just given. Google's sender guidelines add that recipients should opt in, that opt-in forms checked by default are the pattern to avoid and that addresses should not be bought. For a charity this also covers sign-in sheets: an address someone wrote on a clipboard is a reason to send one confirmation email, not a reason to put them on a monthly newsletter.
A short series gives you room that one email does not. A reasonable starting point is three messages: a welcome and a clear next step, a story that shows the work, and a note on how to get more involved. Wait times are yours to set, and the right gap depends on how often you publish. Read Google's sender guidelines, Yahoo's best practices and transactional vs marketing email for the receipt-versus-welcome split.
Five tools compared for a charity welcome series
| Tool | Free or entry | Price at a real list size | Limit that matters |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brevo | Free: 300 sends a day | Starter $9; Standard $18, both from 5,000 emails a month | Free automation covers 2,000 contacts |
| Sender | Free: 2,500 subscribers, 15,000 emails a month | Standard $6.30 (first-year discount price) and Professional $10.50, at 500 subscribers | Sender branding on free |
| MailerLite | Free: 250 subscribers, 2 user seats | Comfort $12 at 500; $49 at 5,000 | Free subscriber ceiling |
| Kit | Free to 10,000 subscribers | Creator $33 at 1,000; $75 at 5,000 | Sequences are not on the free plan |
| Mailchimp | Free: 250 contacts, 500 sends a month | Essentials $13 and Standard $20 at 500; Standard $100 at 2,501 to 5,000 | Essentials has 3 seats, Standard 5 |
Brevo: do the arithmetic on the daily limit first
Imagine 40 new signups a week, each receiving a three-message series. That is 40 x 3 = 120 sends a week, around 17 a day, far below the 300 a day on the free plan, so welcome mail fits. A one-off appeal to the whole list is the message that struggles. The free automation allowance covers 2,000 contacts; a list that has grown past that needs Standard or a closer look at which contacts count. Brevo's help page also lists $9 per extra marketing seat, which matters if several volunteers need logins.
Sender: a free plan with room for 2,500 subscribers
Free Forever allows 2,500 subscribers and 15,000 emails a month with Sender branding, which a charity of that size can live with for a long time. The paid tiers on its page are Standard at $6.30, which the page shows with a 30% first-year discount at 500 subscribers, so ask what year two costs, and Professional at $10.50, which lists 10 role-based seats. The page does not list what automation each plan includes, so build the welcome series on the free plan before you decide.
MailerLite: a simple editor for volunteers
The free plan gives 250 subscribers and 2 user seats, which suits a brand-new organization. Comfort starts at $12 for 500 subscribers and $19 for 1,000, and its page lists email automation and landing pages for sign-up forms. A volunteer without design skills can build the three-step series quickly, and the page states the data storage center is in the European Union.
Kit: free to send, paid to automate
The free plan reaches 10,000 subscribers with forms, landing pages, broadcasts and tagging, which is plenty for a newsletter. The welcome sequence, though, needs Creator at $33 for 1,000 or $75 for 5,000, both quoted on yearly billing, so weigh that cost against what the free plans elsewhere on this page already give you. It lists free migrations and a 14-day trial.
Mailchimp: a charity whose board already knows the name
Free covers 250 contacts and 500 sends a month with 250 a day. Essentials is $13 at 500 contacts, Standard $20 at 500 contacts and $100 for 2,501 to 5,000. Essentials includes 3 seats and Standard 5, handy for a team of coordinators. Read the page's introductory-offer notes before you compare year-two prices.
What a year costs at 500 and 5,000 contacts
At 500 contacts, MailerLite Comfort at $12 is 12 x $12 = $144 a year, Mailchimp Essentials at $13 is $156 and Standard at $20 is $240, all as monthly prices. Brevo and Sender stay at $0 on their free plans, and Kit's free plan is $0 but without the sequence. At 5,000 contacts, MailerLite at $49 is $588 a year and Mailchimp Standard at $100 is $1,200, both monthly prices, a gap of $612 a year (1,200 - 588). Kit Creator at $75 would be $900 a year, but that is a yearly-billing rate, so it is not a like-for-like figure against the other two. A charity that can pay nothing for welcome mail should therefore start with Brevo or Sender and leave the paid choice until the list is bigger.
Matching tool to organization
- Choose Brevo when you want automation on a free plan and your sign-ups trickle in.
- Choose Sender when the list already has a couple of thousand names and the budget is zero.
- Choose MailerLite if a volunteer builds the emails and wants an easy editor.
- Choose Kit if a paid plan for sequences fits the budget or the charity also sells products or runs paid memberships.
- Choose Mailchimp when the board or a funder already uses it and shared seats help.
When you switch, export subscribers with signup date and source, upload the unsubscribed list first, authenticate the sending domain with SPF, DKIM and DMARC, and test the full series with three staff addresses before real signups arrive. More reading: building a newsletter audience, Brevo alternatives, email tools for a low budget and the blog hub.
FAQ
How many emails should a welcome series have?
Three is a common starting point: a welcome with one next step, a story, and a way to get involved. Shorten it if your sign-ups come from a single event where one confirmation does the job.
Can we send a welcome email to a sign-in sheet?
Send one confirmation message asking the person to confirm, and add them to the newsletter only when they do. Handwritten addresses are easy to misread and may not mean the person wanted ongoing mail.
Should the welcome email ask for a donation?
Not for most signups. A newsletter or volunteer welcome that opens with a request feels like a bait and switch. After a first gift, thank the donor and let the receipt come from the donation platform.
Does a nonprofit get a discount?
Ask each vendor whether it has a nonprofit rate before you pay the listed price.