Best email broadcast tools for nonprofits launching a program or product
A nonprofit with a tight budget and a supporter list under a few thousand should look first at EmailOctopus. Its pricing page lists a free plan for up to 2,500 subscribers and 10,000 emails a month, and a Pro plan at $9 a month billed yearly at the slider's default setting, so check the slider for your own list size. The free plan alone is enough room for a four-message launch to a list of a couple of thousand. Brevo suits an organization with a big list and a few sends, MailerLite suits one with a European donor base, and Mailchimp is for teams that already know it.
Who is actually on a nonprofit's list
A product launch in this sector might be a new service for beneficiaries, a merchandise line, a fundraising drive or an app. The list behind it is usually a mix of people who joined for different reasons, and a message that suits one group can embarrass you with another.
- Donors expect to hear where the money went. Launch news that ignores impact reads as a new ask.
- Volunteers want dates, roles and a person to reply to. They are the people most likely to forward the launch.
- Partners and press need a short summary, a link to facts and a contact. Give them their own segment.
- People you serve should not be on a marketing list unless they chose to be. Keep service data apart from the fundraising list, and do not mix them in one export.
Receipts and tax acknowledgements for donations are service mail, and they should leave through the donation platform, not through the launch campaign. Do not add a "check out our new program" block to a receipt.
A launch is four messages, not one
| Message | To whom | What it must contain | Skip a person if |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Early notice | Core supporters and volunteers | What is coming, why now, one way to help before the public launch | They are new to the list this week |
| 2. Launch day | Everyone who agreed to hear from you | What it is, who it is for, the single action, a human sender | They unsubscribed from campaigns |
| 3. Reminder | People who did not act | A short story or number from your own work, and the same action | They already acted |
| 4. Thanks and result | Everyone who acted, plus the list | What happened, in plain figures from your records | Never; it is the message that earns the next launch |
The fourth message is the one nonprofits drop, and it is the one donors remember. Reply addresses matter in this sector: someone will answer a launch email with a real question about eligibility or a donation, so send from an address that a person checks within a day.
Consent and where supporters live
A person who gave once did not necessarily agree to campaign email, and the rules about that differ between countries. Record how each address joined and when, give each message a working unsubscribe link, and do not buy or borrow lists. If you have supporters in the European Union, ask your counsel what applies; MailerLite's pricing page says its data storage center is in the European Union with ISO 27001 and GDPR controls, and Mailchimp publishes a data processing addendum, which can help that review. With any vendor on the shortlist, ask whether it has a nonprofit rate before you pay list price.
Free tiers have send limits, so do the arithmetic first
The free plans look alike until you plan four messages to a real list. Take a nonprofit with 2,000 supporters:
| Free plan | What its page lists | Four launch messages to 2,000 people |
|---|---|---|
| EmailOctopus | 2,500 subscribers, 10,000 emails a month | 4 x 2,000 = 8,000 emails, which fits |
| Brevo | 300 email sends a day | 2,000 / 300 is about 7 days for each message, so about 27 days for four |
| Mailchimp | 250 contacts, 500 sends a month | Does not fit: the list is over the 250-contact limit |
| MailerLite | 250 subscribers, 2,500 emails a month | Does not fit: the list is over the 250-subscriber limit |
Brevo's daily limit is the surprise. A launch-day message that reaches different supporters over a week is not a launch day. If you use its free plan, stagger the plan on purpose or pay for Starter, which its page lists without a daily limit.
Five tools for a nonprofit launch
| Tool | Free or entry | Price at a real list size | Limit that matters |
|---|---|---|---|
| EmailOctopus | Free to 2,500 subscribers | Pro $9 a month, billed yearly, at the default slider setting | Free plan carries EmailOctopus branding |
| Brevo | Free: 300 sends a day | Starter from $9; Standard from $18 | Daily send limit on free |
| MailerLite | Free: 250 subscribers | Comfort $49 at 5,000; $89 at 10,000 | Free list ceiling is 250 |
| Mailchimp | Free: 250 contacts | Standard $100 at 2,501-5,000; $135 at 5,001-10,000 | Free is 500 sends a month |
| Constant Contact | Free trial, no free plan | Lite from $12; Standard from $35 | Lite is 1 user |
EmailOctopus: a free plan with room for a small supporter list
Free covers 2,500 subscribers with one landing page and form and one user, and keeps reports for 30 days. Pro lists unlimited landing pages, forms and users, and reports kept forever, at $9 a month billed yearly at the slider's default setting, which the page pairs with 10,000 emails a month. A launch of four messages to 10,000 supporters is 40,000 sends, so read the slider at your own subscriber count and email volume before you count on $9. For a charity run by two volunteers, the unlimited users matter as much as the price.
Brevo: a big list that you write to rarely
The free plan lists storage for up to 100,000 contacts, with 2,000 contacts in marketing automation and 300 email sends a day, so a charity with a long list and a few big sends a year can start without a bill. Starter starts at $9 a month for 5,000 emails and Standard at $18 lists A/B testing and advanced reports. Its feature list also includes transactional email and SMS. See Brevo alternatives.
MailerLite: when donors are across Europe
Its free plan lists 2 user seats, which suits a small team, and the pricing page names an EU data storage center, ISO 27001 and GDPR controls. The free plan stops at 250 subscribers, so most real supporter lists land on Comfort at $19 for 1,000 or $49 for 5,000. Landing pages and automation are on its feature list. Compare it in MailerLite vs Mailchimp.
Mailchimp: familiar to volunteers, expensive at scale
The free plan is 1 audience, 250 contacts and 500 sends a month, and the pricing page shows Standard at $100 for 2,501 to 5,000 contacts. Standard has 5 seats and Essentials 3, which helps when several people draft and approve. The page also shows first-year promotions on some bands. Use it when a board member or volunteer already knows how it works and the list is small.
Constant Contact: seats for staff and a predictable monthly line
Its page lists Lite from $12 ($10.20 billed annually) with 1 user, Standard from $35 ($29.75 annually) with 3 users and automation, and Premium from $80 with unlimited users. The exact price depends on the number of contacts. There is no free plan, only a free trial, so it fits an organization with paid staff, several approvers and a steady monthly budget.
What a year costs on each route
For a 10,000-supporter list on monthly billing: MailerLite Comfort $89 x 12 = $1,068 and Mailchimp Standard $135 x 12 = $1,620. The gap between them is $1,620 - $1,068 = $552 a year. EmailOctopus is left out of that comparison on purpose: its $9 is a yearly-billed rate at a default slider setting, so work out its price at your own list size and email volume on its page before comparing it with these monthly figures. At 5,000 supporters, MailerLite is $49 x 12 = $588 against Mailchimp's $100 x 12 = $1,200, a difference of $612.
How to choose, and how to switch
- Choose EmailOctopus if your list is under 2,500 and the budget is zero, or you want a yearly-billed plan to price at your own list size.
- Choose Brevo if the list is long, sends are rare and a daily limit is tolerable.
- Choose MailerLite if EU supporters and a written data-handling answer matter.
- Choose Constant Contact if several staff need seats and budget is predictable.
- Choose Mailchimp if volunteers already run it.
To move, export supporters with their joined date and source, the opt-out list and any donor-level tags, and do not import anyone who opted out. Set up SPF, DKIM and DMARC for your organization's domain on the new tool and send a test to a few supporters' addresses before the launch. For more on process, read the email broadcast guide and building a newsletter audience.
FAQ
Can a nonprofit use a free plan for a real launch?
Yes, if the list and the number of messages fit the cap. Work out the sends before you choose: four messages to 2,000 people is 8,000 emails, which fits EmailOctopus's free plan and not Mailchimp's.
Should donors and volunteers get the same launch email?
Not usually. Donors want impact and a clear ask, volunteers want dates and roles. Two short versions beat one long message that tries to cover both.
Is a thank-you after a launch really necessary?
It is the message most likely to be read by the people who helped. Send it with the result in plain figures from your records, and no new ask.
How do we handle donors who unsubscribe from campaigns but still give?
Respect the unsubscribe for campaigns and keep their receipts flowing from your donation platform. Do not re-add them for the next launch.