Best email broadcast tools for nonprofits growing a newsletter
A small nonprofit that wants more supporters on its newsletter without a software bill should try Kit first. Its pricing page lists a free plan up to 10,000 subscribers, with unlimited landing pages, forms and email broadcasts plus tagging and segmentation, and the paid Creator plan, which starts at $33 a month for 1,000 subscribers, only becomes necessary when you want automated welcome sequences. A board treasurer can read that page in two minutes.
Where new subscribers actually come from
Newsletter growth at a nonprofit is mostly a matter of putting one honest sign-up box in the places supporters already visit. A list of the usual doorways, with what each one needs from the tool:
- The donation thank-you page. The donor has just acted; offer the newsletter as a separate, unticked choice. You need a form that can be embedded on a page you control.
- Volunteer and event registration. A checkbox on the form, not an assumption. You need tags, so "volunteer" and "event attendee" stay distinguishable.
- Printed material. A short URL or QR code leading to a hosted landing page, which suits tools with built-in pages.
- Partners and the board's networks. A forwardable issue with a visible subscribe link, or a referral feature if the tool has one.
- The website. A form in the footer and one at the end of each story.
Donors are not automatically subscribers
The easiest way to wreck a nonprofit list is to import every donor and volunteer into the newsletter because they are "already supporters". Giving money, or turning up to a food drive, is not the same as asking for a newsletter. Google's sender guidelines tell senders to get opt-in and to avoid pre-checked boxes, and an unexpected newsletter is a quick way to collect spam complaints from your most loyal people. Keep these groups separate:
- people who subscribed to the newsletter (broadcast to them);
- donors who gave without subscribing (receipts and thank-yous are service mail, and anything else needs their agreement);
- volunteers (operational emails about shifts are a different stream from a monthly story).
If you hold an old list from a coalition or a previous director, ask for proof of how people joined, and send a single "do you still want this?" email rather than treating them as current subscribers. For the broader craft of keeping readers, see building a newsletter audience.
Plan for the volunteer who leaves
Nonprofit email tools are usually run by one person, and that person moves on. Put the account in a shared role address such as newsletter@ your domain, not a personal inbox, record who has access, and choose a tool whose seat limits fit your reality. EmailOctopus lists 1 user on its free plan and unlimited users on Pro; MailerLite lists 2 user seats on free; Mailchimp's free plan has 1 seat; Kit lists unlimited users on Pro. Whichever tool you choose, publish SPF and DKIM for your domain so the newsletter does not depend on one person's login or a third-party sender address.
Six tools compared for a growing supporter list
| Tool | Free tier | Entry price | Price at a real list size | Limit that matters here |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kit | Free to 10,000 subscribers | Creator $33 at 1,000 | Creator $75 at 5,000; $116 at 10,000 | Sequences need Creator |
| EmailOctopus | 2,500 subscribers, 10,000 emails a month | Pro $9 a month, billed yearly | Rises with the subscriber count you select | Free carries EmailOctopus branding and 1 user |
| MailerLite | 250 subscribers, 2,500 emails a month | Comfort $19 at 1,000 | Comfort $49 at 5,000; $89 at 10,000 | Free ceiling is 250 subscribers |
| Brevo | 300 sends a day, 100,000 contacts stored | Starter $9; Standard $18 | Set by email volume selected | Daily limit on Free |
| Mailchimp | 250 contacts, 500 sends a month | Standard $20 at 500 contacts | $100 at 2,501-5,000; $135 at 5,001-10,000 | 500 sends a month on Free |
| Constant Contact | Free trial only | Lite $12; Standard $35 | Rises with contact count | No free plan |
Kit: free forms and pages while the list is still growing
Kit's free plan lists unlimited landing pages and forms, so every doorway above can have its own sign-up form at no cost, and tagging lets you see which door each person used. Growth tooling worth knowing about: the Pro plan ($66 at 1,000 subscribers, with a first-year $50 shown) lists a newsletter referral system, which suits a supporter base that forwards issues. The honest limit is that welcome sequences and automations start on Creator at $33, billed yearly at the 1,000 stop. See Kit (ConvertKit) alternatives.
EmailOctopus: the budget route with a clear monthly ceiling
EmailOctopus's free plan lists 2,500 subscribers and 10,000 emails a month, with its own branding on emails, reports kept for 30 days and 1 landing page and form. Those numbers fit together neatly: 2,500 subscribers receiving four issues a month is exactly 10,000 emails. Pro, at $9 a month billed yearly on the page, lists unlimited landing pages, forms and users and keeps reports forever, which solves the volunteer handover problem cheaply.
MailerLite: when a pretty page matters more than a free plan
MailerLite lists landing pages, websites and automation, and a free plan of 250 subscribers and 2 user seats. Most supporter lists outgrow 250 quickly, so plan for Comfort at $19 for 1,000 subscribers. Its page states that its data storage center is in the European Union with an ISO 27001 certificate, which can help a charity with European donors answer a question from its board, though your own data protection duties still apply. Compare in MailerLite vs Mailchimp.
Brevo: a big contact store with a small daily quota
Brevo keeps up to 100,000 contacts on the free plan but limits sends to 300 a day, so a 3,000-person newsletter would take ten days to deliver one issue. That is a poor fit for a time-sensitive appeal. Starter at $9 removes the daily cap from a starting volume of 5,000 emails a month. Brevo suits a charity that wants transactional and marketing mail from one vendor and can tolerate the plan arithmetic. See Brevo alternatives.
Mailchimp and Constant Contact: contact-based pricing, one with a free plan
Mailchimp's free plan stops at 250 contacts and 500 sends a month; its Standard bands cost $100 and then $135 at 5,000 and 10,000 contacts. Constant Contact has no free plan, only a free trial, and lists Lite from $12 and Standard from $35 with prices that rise with contacts. If either already holds your list and the bill is approved, staying put avoids a migration. Ask each vendor whether it has a nonprofit rate.
Yearly cost for three sizes of supporter list
Assume 2,500, 5,000 and 10,000 subscribers, and four sends a month.
| Tool and plan | 2,500 subscribers | 5,000 | 10,000 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kit Free | $0 (10,000 emails sent) | $0 (20,000 sent) | $0 (40,000 sent) |
| MailerLite Comfort | n/a | $49 x 12 = $588 | $89 x 12 = $1,068 |
| Mailchimp Standard | n/a | $100 x 12 = $1,200 | $135 x 12 = $1,620 |
At 5,000 supporters, Mailchimp costs $1,200 a year against Kit's $0, and $612 more than MailerLite (1,200 - 588). The Kit saving disappears if you want automated welcome sequences, since Creator is $75 at 5,000, or $900 a year (75 x 12), which looks $300 below Mailchimp's $1,200. That gap mixes billing bases, though: Kit's $75 is its yearly-billing rate and Mailchimp's $100 is monthly-billed, so the true difference is smaller if you pay Kit month to month. Check each page for the current offer before you present a budget.
Which to pick, and how to move
- Kit for growth work: free forms and pages up to 10,000, and a referral feature on Pro.
- EmailOctopus when the list is under 2,500 and four issues a month is the plan, or when unlimited users on Pro solves a handover worry.
- MailerLite if you want designed pages and an EU storage statement and have budget for 1,000 or more subscribers.
- Brevo if you also need service mail and your volume per day is modest.
To move, export the list with the sign-up source and date, plus a separate unsubscribe file, and import the unsubscribes before the active list. Update every embedded form and QR code destination after the new forms exist, since printed material will keep sending people to the old address for months. See the guide to choosing an email tool and the tools directory.
FAQ
Can we add everyone who has ever donated to the newsletter?
No. Donation is not agreement to receive a newsletter. Send donors a single invitation to subscribe, and add only those who say yes. Receipts and thank-yous can go to donors as service mail.
How often should a nonprofit newsletter go out?
Whatever you told subscribers on the form. A monthly story plus an occasional appeal is a common pattern, but a list that signed up for monthly mail will complain if it receives weekly mail.
Do we need a custom sending domain?
Yes, if you can set one up. Authenticating your own domain with SPF and DKIM makes the newsletter look like it comes from you and lets you keep the same sender when you switch tools.
What is the quickest way to grow the list this month?
Add a clear newsletter option to the donation thank-you page and to every volunteer and event form, then link to a hosted sign-up page from your social profiles and printed materials.