Best email broadcast tools for ecommerce stores growing a newsletter
If your store runs on Shopify, begin with Shopify Email: Shopify's help page says the first 10,000 emails each month are free, and pricing after that starts at $1 per 1,000. A store that grows from a few hundred subscribers to several thousand pays little or nothing while it learns what its audience wants. Move to Klaviyo, whose pricing page lists $30 a month at 1,000 profiles, once you want automations and segmentation built around store behavior. Off Shopify, MailerLite is the cheaper general-purpose route.
Where new subscribers come from, and what each source owes them
Newsletter growth in a store is a set of small doors, each with its own promise. The tool you pick matters less than being honest at each door, because the way people join decides how many of them will still read your email in six months.
| Door | What the shopper should be told | What breaks if you skip it |
|---|---|---|
| Footer or page form | What the emails are and how often | Subscribers expecting weekly mail get monthly, or the reverse |
| Pop-up with an incentive | What the code is worth, and that mail follows | Code collectors who never open anything |
| Checkout tick box | A plain, unticked opt-in for marketing | Complaints from people who thought they were getting a receipt |
| Post-purchase page | That this is a separate list from order updates | Order mail and promotions tangled together |
| Social or giveaway entry | That entering adds you to the list, in the entry terms | Contest addresses that bounce or report spam |
Two of those doors are risky. Google's sender guidelines say opt-in boxes should not be checked by default, and Yahoo's Sender Hub rules out purchased lists and pre-ticked boxes. A checkout box that is ticked for the customer grows the list quickly and then shows up as complaints, which Google tells senders to keep very low. Order confirmations and shipping notices are service mail and should not carry promotional blocks beyond what the platform allows; that split is explained in transactional vs marketing email.
Growth has a bill: you pay for contacts, not only for sends
Every tool here prices by list size or contact count, with one exception: Shopify Email prices by emails sent. That changes what "growth" costs. A list of 10,000 where 4,000 people stopped opening a year ago still counts toward a plan. Omnisend's pricing page says it bills subscribers and non-subscribers who received automated messages, and does not bill unsubscribed contacts. Klaviyo's pricing is by active profiles. So the growth plan includes a clean-up plan: a re-engagement email to the quiet, then removal of those who do not respond, before you move up a price band.
Measure growth by source and by what each group buys. A pop-up that adds 400 contacts a month and a footer form that adds 40 are different businesses once you look at first-order rates, so tag each signup with the door it used.
Six tools compared for a store newsletter
| Tool | Free or entry | Price at real list sizes | Limit that matters |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shopify Email | First 10,000 emails a month free | $1 per 1,000 emails after that (starting rate) | A Shopify app, so only for Shopify stores |
| Klaviyo | Free: 250 profiles, 500 emails a month | $30 at 1,000; $100 at 5,000; $150 at 10,000 | Email volume capped at 10x profiles |
| Omnisend | Free: 250 contacts, 500 emails a month | Standard $11.20 and Pro $41.30 shown as first-three-month offers | Standard sends 6,000 emails a month at 500 contacts |
| Privy | No free plan listed | $30 a month for mailable contacts | Priced on mailable contacts only |
| MailerLite | Free: 250 subscribers, 2,500 emails a month | Comfort $19 at 1,000; $49 at 5,000; $89 at 10,000 | Free tier is too small for a growing store |
| Mailchimp | Free: 250 contacts, 500 sends a month | Standard $100 at 2,501-5,000; $135 at 5,001-10,000 | Prices jump by contact band |
Shopify Email: pay for sending, not for the list
The cost model is simple and unusual: 10,000 emails a month are free, then pricing starts at $1 per 1,000, all billed in USD. Because the meter counts emails rather than contacts, a list full of occasional readers costs nothing extra. The limit is that it lives inside Shopify; if you ever move the store, the newsletter tool does not come along, so keep an export of subscribers and consent dates.
Klaviyo: when store data should decide who gets what
The pricing page lists a free plan for 250 profiles with 500 emails a month, then email plans at $20 for 500 profiles, $60 for 2,500, $100 for 5,000, $150 for 10,000 and $400 for 25,000. Each step allows ten times the profile count in monthly emails. The jump from $150 to $400 between 10,000 and 25,000 profiles is the number to plan around, because it arrives just as a store's list starts to grow quickly. See Klaviyo alternatives if the slope bothers you.
Omnisend: email and SMS from one account
Omnisend's page lists a free plan of 250 contacts, 500 emails and 500 web push notifications a month, with Standard at 6,000 emails for 500 contacts and Pro with unlimited emails; SMS is priced separately, starting at $0.007 per message. The Standard and Pro prices it shows, $11.20 and $41.30 a month, are first-three-month upfront offer rates (the page puts Standard at $33.60 today against $48.00 in total, which is $16 a month), so budget a year at the regular rate, not the offer. It lists transactional email and forms among its features, and publishes a data processing agreement.
Privy: sign-up capture priced by mailable contacts
Privy's page lists email at $30 a month for mailable contacts with unlimited sends, and its Shopify App Store listing shows plans from $24 a month. Paying only for contacts you can actually mail is fair for a growing store with many one-time buyers. Read its signup tools on the vendor page before you commit, since this guide cites only its price and billing basis.
MailerLite: the low-cost general option
MailerLite's Comfort plan is $19 at 1,000 subscribers, $49 at 5,000, $89 at 10,000 and $179 at 25,000, and its page lists Shopify and WooCommerce among integrations. Use it when you want a newsletter and basic automation without store-specific tooling. It does not send transactional mail.
Mailchimp: familiar, but the bands add up
Mailchimp's free plan is 1 audience, 250 contacts and 500 sends a month, and Standard is $20 at 500 contacts, $100 for 2,501 to 5,000 and $135 for 5,001 to 10,000. The page shows 50% off the first 12 months for those bands, but the standing price is the one to budget. Its page lists audience segmentation, automation and A/B testing. See MailerLite vs Mailchimp.
What a growing list costs: 1,000, 5,000 and 10,000 subscribers
Assume a weekly newsletter, 4 emails a month. That is 4,000 emails at 1,000 subscribers, 20,000 at 5,000 and 40,000 at 10,000.
| Tool | 1,000 | 5,000 | 10,000 | Per year at 10,000 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shopify Email | $0 | $10 | $30 | $30 x 12 = $360 |
| MailerLite Comfort | $19 | $49 | $89 | $89 x 12 = $1,068 |
| Mailchimp Standard | n/a | $100 | $135 | $135 x 12 = $1,620 |
| Klaviyo Email | $30 | $100 | $150 | $150 x 12 = $1,800 |
The Shopify Email row assumes the $1-per-1,000 starting rate applies above the free 10,000: 20,000 emails leave 10,000 billable, which is $10, and 40,000 leave 30,000, which is $30. At 10,000 subscribers the gap between Shopify Email and Klaviyo is $1,440 a year ($1,800 minus $360). That gap is what you pay for the Klaviyo feature set, so the question is whether segmentation and automation will recover it. The two sending caps hold in the example: MailerLite Comfort at the 10,000 tier allows 100,000 emails a month, and Klaviyo's 10,000-profile plan allows 100,000, so 40,000 fits both.
Picking a tool for your store
- Choose Shopify Email if you are on Shopify, run a plain newsletter, and want the free allowance to carry you.
- Choose Klaviyo if the list is the main revenue channel and you will build flows around browsing and purchase history.
- Choose Omnisend if SMS and web push will be part of the mix and you want one bill.
- Choose MailerLite if you want a low recurring price outside Shopify (Comfort is $89 at 10,000 subscribers on monthly billing).
- Choose Mailchimp if your team already knows it and the list will stay under a band boundary.
Moving a store's list without losing consent
Export every contact with signup date, source tag and subscribed status, and export the unsubscribed list separately. Import suppression first so nobody who opted out is mailed from the new tool. Authenticate the store's sending domain with SPF, DKIM and DMARC on the new platform, then send a normal newsletter to your most engaged group before the full list. Rebuild the welcome message and test the signup form, pop-up and checkout box with a real order.
Related reading: newsletter best practices, building a newsletter audience and the blog hub.
FAQ
Should every customer be added to the newsletter?
No. A purchase is not consent to marketing, and Google and Yahoo both say addresses should come from a clear opt-in. Add customers who ticked an unchecked box or signed up on a form, and keep order updates on service mail.
Is a discount code worth offering for signup?
It grows the list fast and also attracts people who only want the code. If you use one, say what the code is worth and that emails follow, tag the signups, and watch how many of them place a second order before you scale it.
Does double opt-in help a store?
It keeps typos and fake addresses off the list, and Google's guidelines say each address should be confirmed. The cost is some lost signups, so a store with a bounce problem benefits most.
When is a list too big to be cheap?
When a large part of it never opens. Plans such as Klaviyo's price by profile, so 10,000 profiles is $150 whether or not 4,000 of them are active. Run a re-engagement email, remove the silent group, and the next price band moves back.