Best email broadcast tools for welcoming new community members
Pick Brevo if you are launching a community and want the welcome sequence running before you have a budget. Brevo's help centre lists a free plan with 300 email sends a day and up to 2,000 contacts in marketing automation, which is more than enough for the first months of joins; the paid Starter plan from $9 a month removes the daily cap once a launch day brings more people than the free plan can serve.
The first hour after joining matters more than the first month
A person who just joined your Slack group, forum or paid membership is as engaged as they will ever be. They have the tab open, they are curious about who else is in the room, and they have no habit yet. A welcome email that reaches them during that hour has a very different job from a newsletter: it tells them where to go, what to say and who to ask. Send it from the moment of joining, not from a nightly batch.
That sets the first requirement for a tool: the welcome must be triggered by the join event, either from a form on the signup page or from a connector with the community platform. Check that before comparing prices. A tool that can only import a CSV once a day is a newsletter tool, not a welcome tool.
A first-week sequence for a community
- Immediately: the doorway. Three things only: the link to the main space, the one rule that matters most (the code of conduct, linked), and the name of the person who runs the community. Say which email address the replies go to.
- Day 2: say hello. A prompt to post a short introduction, with a link to the thread, and two examples of good ones from existing members (with their permission).
- Day 4: where the action is. The two or three channels or boards most newcomers find useful, and the next event on the calendar.
- Day 7: tune the noise. How to set notification preferences on the community platform, and a preference link to choose a weekly digest or no further emails. Skipping this step is how welcome campaigns turn into spam complaints.
If a new member posts their first message on day one, drop them out of the day-two prompt; nothing sounds more automated than asking someone to do what they just did. This exit condition, based on a tag the community platform or your connector writes, is the second thing to test in a trial.
Join-day spikes and the daily cap
Communities get their joiners in bursts: a launch announcement, a conference mention, a podcast guest slot. Suppose 1,200 people join on launch day. On Brevo's free plan, one welcome email each is 1,200 sends against a cap of 300 a day, which spreads delivery over four days (1,200 divided by 300), so the last arrivals receive their "welcome" days after joining. A five-email sequence for 400 new joiners a month is 2,000 sends, which is fine over a month; it is the single-day spike that breaks the free plan. The practical fix is either to upgrade on launch week or to send an instant welcome from the community platform and leave the email sequence for day two onward.
Consent and expectations at the door
Joining a community does not automatically subscribe someone to your marketing. Put a checkbox, unticked by default, for emails beyond essential account mail, and say how often you will write. Yahoo's sender best practices and Google's sender guidelines both ask for expectation-setting at signup and an easy unsubscribe, and the welcome sequence is where you honour that. Every email needs a working unsubscribe link even when it feels like a service message.
Six tools for a welcome sequence
| Tool | Free plan or entry | Price at a real list size | Limit that matters |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brevo | Free: 300 sends a day | Starter from $9, Standard from $18 | Daily cap on free; 2,000 contacts in automation |
| MailerLite | Free: 250 subscribers, 2,500 emails a month | Comfort $19 at 1,000; $49 at 5,000 | Free ceiling of 250 subscribers |
| Kit | Free to 10,000 subscribers | Creator $33 at 1,000; $75 at 5,000 (billed yearly) | Welcome sequence needs the paid plan |
| Flodesk | Free: forms and pages, no sending | Pro $28 at 1,000; $59 at 5,000 (monthly) | Lite includes only 1 workflow |
| ActiveCampaign | No free plan; Starter $15 at 1,000 | Starter $39 at 2,500; $79 at 5,000 (billed annually) | 5 actions per automation on Starter |
| EmailOctopus | Free: 2,500 subscribers, 10,000 emails | Pro shown as $9, billed yearly, at the page's default setting | Branding on free; reports kept 30 days |
Brevo: a welcome sequence on the free plan
Beyond the free plan, Standard at $18 adds A/B testing and advanced reports to automation, which lets you try two doorway subject lines. Brevo's page lists transactional email too, so a community that sends its own account notices from the same vendor can keep both streams in one place. Keep them on separate From addresses. The weakness is the one described above: a launch-day spike beats the 300-a-day cap.
MailerLite: simple automation for a modest community
MailerLite lists automation, landing pages and a free plan with 2 seats, so a co-founder can help with the sequence. Comfort is $19 a month at 1,000 subscribers and $49 at 5,000. It is a good match for a community that mostly needs the four-step sequence and a signup page.
Kit: welcome through a sequence, tags for the interests
Kit's Creator plan lists unlimited sequences and Visual Automations. A new member who ticks "events" on the join form can receive a different day-four email from one who ticks "jobs board". Creator is $33 at 1,000 subscribers and $75 at 5,000. Before paying, you can still send broadcasts on the free plan.
Flodesk: the designed welcome
Flodesk's Pro plan lists unlimited workflows at $28 a month for up to 1,000 subscribers, $39 at 2,500 and $59 at 5,000. Because its free plan has forms and landing pages but no sending, it is a tool for communities that already know they will pay and care about the look of the doorway email.
ActiveCampaign: for membership communities tied to payments or sales
It lists marketing automation, a standard CRM and ecommerce integrations. Starter costs $15 at 1,000 contacts, $39 at 2,500 and $79 at 5,000, but a welcome sequence with exit conditions and tags will pass the 5-action limit, so Plus at $49 for 1,000 contacts is the realistic tier for a paid membership.
EmailOctopus: the low-cost option for a large free list
EmailOctopus's free plan allows 2,500 subscribers and 10,000 emails a month, and Pro is shown at $9 a month billed yearly at the pricing page's default setting; the page does not make clear whether its 10,000 is a subscriber count or an email allowance, so price your own list before comparing. It suits a free community with a plain doorway email, though its automation options deserve a trial first, since the pricing page lists reports and landing pages rather than workflow limits.
The same community at 1,000 and 5,000 members
| Plan | 1,000 | 5,000 | Per year at 5,000 |
|---|---|---|---|
| MailerLite Comfort (billed monthly) | $19 | $49 | 12 x $49 = $588 |
| Flodesk Pro (billed monthly) | $28 | $59 | 12 x $59 = $708 |
| Flodesk Pro (billed yearly) | - | $54 | 12 x $54 = $648 |
| Kit Creator (billed yearly) | $33 | $75 | 12 x $75 = $900 |
| ActiveCampaign Starter (billed annually) | $15 | $79 | 12 x $79 = $948 |
Compare within a billing basis. On monthly billing, MailerLite Comfort at $588 a year is $120 below Flodesk Pro at $708 ($708 minus $588). On yearly billing, Flodesk Pro at $648 is $252 below Kit Creator at $900 and $300 below ActiveCampaign Starter at $948. ActiveCampaign Starter is the lowest-priced row at 1,000 ($15) and the highest at 5,000, a reminder that you should price the list you expect in a year, not the one you have today. Brevo's price depends on monthly emails rather than contacts, so a community with 5,000 members that sends the five-email welcome to 400 joiners and a monthly newsletter sends about 2,000 + 5,000 = 7,000 emails a month, above the 5,000 where its tiers begin.
Choosing, and moving a community's list
- Choose Brevo to launch for nothing and upgrade at the first spike.
- Choose MailerLite for a simple four-step sequence and signup page once you pass 250 subscribers.
- Choose Kit if interests chosen at signup should shape the sequence.
- Choose ActiveCampaign for paid memberships with a sales or billing side.
To move, export members with their join date, the interests ticked and consent status, then pause the welcome sequence on the old tool so new joiners do not get two. Add SPF, DKIM and DMARC for the new sender and test the join event with a fresh email address. Read the email broadcast guide, building a newsletter audience and Brevo alternatives, or return to the blog hub.
FAQ
Should the welcome email come from the community platform or an email tool?
Use the platform for the instant doorway message if it can send one, and your email tool for the sequence that follows. That keeps the first message fast even when a spike hits a sending cap.
How many welcome emails are enough?
Four over the first week covers the doorway, an introduction prompt, a tour and a preferences message. Any more should depend on what the member did.
Do welcome emails need an unsubscribe link?
Yes, when they carry anything beyond account essentials. A tips-and-events welcome is marketing in practice, and a visible unsubscribe link costs you nothing.
What if someone joins twice with different addresses?
Treat them as two contacts until the person tells you otherwise, and avoid merging them silently. Most tools bill each address, so a clean-up after a few months also trims the invoice.