Best email broadcast tools for publishers distributing their articles
A publisher that sends frequently should start by pricing frequency, and beehiiv has a free plan that fits that arithmetic: its pricing page lists up to 2,500 subscribers with unlimited email sends, 1 publication and 1 team seat. Lite is $49 a month under yearly billing, and beehiiv's page says it takes 0% of paid subscription revenue apart from Stripe's processing fee of 2.9% plus $0.30 per transaction. Publishers who mail every day will not run into a send allowance in the first stage.
Frequency decides the plan: the arithmetic of a daily digest
Most plans meter sends against subscribers, which a publisher notices only after the first month of daily issues. Take a publication with 10,000 subscribers. A weekly issue is 4 sends a month, or 40,000 emails. Twenty-two weekday issues are 220,000. A daily issue is 30 x 10,000 = 300,000.
Now compare with the published allowances. MailerLite's Comfort plan gives ten times the ceiling of your subscriber tier, which at the 10,000 tier is 100,000 emails; its Power plan lists unlimited emails. Campaign Monitor's Lite plan lists 5x subscribers a month, or 50,000 at 10,000, while Essentials lists unlimited sends. MailerLite's free plan allows up to 250 subscribers and 2,500 emails a month, so a daily issue to 250 readers uses the whole allowance in ten days (250 x 10 = 2,500). So a weekly publisher fits the cheaper plan of either, a weekday publisher needs the unlimited one, and the free plan of anything with a monthly cap is only a trial. Work out your emails a month before you look at the headline price.
From the content system to the inbox
Publishers already have a content system, so the question is how an article gets into an email. Ghost does it natively, since the newsletter and the site are one product. Buttondown's pricing page lists RSS-to-email among its features, so a publication with a feed can send its latest items without re-pasting them. With the others you paste or import the issue. Whichever way you go, three habits help readers: one canonical web URL for every issue, the web version linked at the top, and a correction policy that sends a short follow-up when a published fact turns out wrong, instead of editing silently on the site.
Segment by beat, not by guesswork. A reader who signed up for the politics newsletter should not receive the lifestyle digest because the tool defaults everyone to one list. Use separate lists or tags per beat, and put the choice on the signup form. Buttondown prices tagging and segmentation as a +$9 a month add-on and multiple newsletters as +$29; for the other tools, check the vendor's own page for what separate beats need.
What the platform takes from reader revenue
If the publication sells subscriptions, platform terms matter more than the subscription price of the tool. Substack's pricing page says it keeps 10% of subscription revenue and Stripe charges its own fees. beehiiv's says 0% apart from Stripe's fee. On $2,000 of subscription revenue in a month, Substack's 10% is $200, while beehiiv's listed take rate is $0; the Stripe processing charge applies in both cases, so it does not change the comparison. Buttondown lists paid subscriptions as a +$9 a month add-on, and Ghost(Pro) lists paid subscriptions from its $29 Publisher plan up.
Also read the exit terms. Substack's help page states that exporting a file with subscriber names is not currently possible, which is a real cost for a publisher that may want to leave later. Ask every vendor what leaves with you.
Readers' consent and habits
A reader who commented on an article or created a site account has not agreed to a daily email. Offer the newsletter on the page, with no pre-ticked boxes, say how often you publish, and keep unsubscribing to one click. Google asks bulk senders, meaning those sending 5,000 or more messages a day to Gmail addresses, for SPF, DKIM and DMARC and for one-click unsubscribe on marketing mail; see its sender guidelines. Only messages to Gmail addresses count toward that threshold, so a daily digest to 10,000 readers reaches it only if at least 5,000 of them use Gmail addresses; a growing daily publisher should plan to meet the rules before it gets there.
Six platforms for sending articles
| Tool | Free tier | Prices at reader counts | Limit for a publisher |
|---|---|---|---|
| beehiiv | 2,500 subscribers, unlimited sends | Lite $109 at 5,000 monthly ($95 yearly); $139 at 10,000 ($119 yearly) | Free: 1 publication, 1 seat |
| Ghost | None; hosted plans | Starter $15; Publisher $29 at 1,000 members; Business $199 up to 10,000 (billed yearly) | Starter has no paid subscriptions |
| Buttondown | First 100 subscribers | Add-ons from +$9 to +$79 | Priced by a subscriber slider; the price above 100 subscribers was not read |
| Substack | Publish free | 10% of subscription revenue plus card fees | Emails still send from a substack.com address |
| MailerLite | 250 subscribers, 2,500 emails | Comfort $49 at 5,000; $89 at 10,000; Power $69 and $129 | Comfort allows 10x the subscriber tier |
| Campaign Monitor | 30-day trial: 500 contacts | Lite $75 at 5,000; $117 at 10,000; Essentials $117 and $182 | Lite allows 5x subscribers |
beehiiv: subscriptions and ads with an unlimited-send free start
Lite lists paid subscriptions, automations and audience polls with 2 team seats; Pro lists advanced analytics and 10 seats. Price climbs with the subscriber slider, and the page shows an average ad-monetization figure of $39 a month on the Lite and Pro cards, which is beehiiv's own number, not a promise. It fits a publisher who wants subscriptions and ads in the same product.
Ghost: the publication and its newsletter as one site
Starter at $15 (1,000 members, 1 staff user, billed yearly) lacks paid subscriptions, Publisher at $29 adds 3 staff users, custom themes and paid subscriptions, and Business at $199 covers up to 10,000 members with 15 staff users. It is the tool for a publisher who wants full control of the site, the archive and the email, at the cost of paying for hosting from the start.
Buttondown: lean, text-forward and transparent about add-ons
Nothing is charged for the first 100 subscribers, and the base includes a Markdown or rich-text editor, a custom sending domain and hosted archives. RSS-to-email and sponsorships sit in the +$9 group; Automations are +$29 and Teams +$79. It suits small independent titles. Buttondown's page prices subscribers with a slider and says it charges for active subscribers only, but the price above 100 subscribers was not read, so check the slider at your size before you plan a 10,000-reader budget.
Substack: no monthly fee, two exit questions
There is no monthly fee, a $50 one-time custom domain fee, and the substack.com sending address stays even with a custom domain. If you are a publisher with a brand, the sender address and the export without names are the two issues to weigh before building your list there.
MailerLite: weekly issues on Comfort, daily on Power
Comfort at $89 for 10,000 subscribers handles a weekly issue with 60,000 emails to spare (100,000 minus 40,000), and the Power plan at $129 lists unlimited emails for daily sending. It lists landing pages and websites. Its data storage is in the European Union, according to its pricing page.
Campaign Monitor: Essentials for frequent senders
Lite at $117 for 10,000 contacts has the 5x limit, so a weekly issue (40,000) fits and a weekday issue does not. Essentials at $182 lists unlimited sends. Pick it when you send often enough that Lite's ceiling would cap an issue, and compare Essentials against MailerLite's Power before you decide.
Ten thousand readers, three frequencies
| Frequency | Emails a month | MailerLite (monthly billing) | Campaign Monitor (monthly billing) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Weekly | 4 x 10,000 = 40,000 | Comfort $89 (limit 100,000) | Lite $117 (limit 50,000) |
| Weekdays (22 issues) | 22 x 10,000 = 220,000 | Power $129 (unlimited) | Essentials $182 (unlimited) |
| Daily (30 issues) | 30 x 10,000 = 300,000 | Power $129 | Essentials $182 |
A weekly publisher saves $28 a month on MailerLite against Campaign Monitor (117 minus 89), which is $336 a year (28 x 12). A daily publisher saves $53 a month (182 minus 129), or $636 a year (53 x 12). Ghost Business at $199 (billed yearly) is the comparison for a publisher that wants the site included, and beehiiv Lite at $139 on its monthly-billing view is the comparison for one that wants ads and subscriptions; the sums here are the sending cost only.
Which to choose, and what to do when you switch
- Choose beehiiv for a publication that will carry ads and paid tiers.
- Choose Ghost if you want the site, archive and email in one place.
- Choose Buttondown for a small, text-first title with an RSS feed.
- Choose Substack for a single writer who accepts its address and fee.
- Choose MailerLite or Campaign Monitor for a sender whose frequency makes the volume arithmetic above decide the plan.
Before moving, export subscribers with their beats and signup dates, and the unsubscribe list, and import the latter first. Publish SPF, DKIM and DMARC on the new tool, keep the old issue URLs live or redirected so search traffic survives, and send a test issue to a Gmail and an Outlook address. If subscribers pay, plan the billing handover with each vendor before announcing the change. More background is in newsletter best practices, Ghost vs Substack and beehiiv vs Substack, and the blog hub.
FAQ
Should we email full articles or excerpts?
It depends on how you earn. If you sell ads on the site, an excerpt sends readers there; if the newsletter carries the sponsors or the paid tier, the full text keeps them in the email. Decide once, tell readers, and keep the pattern consistent.
Can a publisher use RSS-to-email?
Yes, where the tool lists it; Buttondown's page names RSS-to-email in its add-on group. Read the first automated issue before it goes to subscribers, because a feed item is formatted for the web, not the inbox.
How do we avoid annoying readers when we publish daily?
Say the frequency on the signup form, offer a weekly digest option through a separate list or tag, and keep a clear unsubscribe link in each issue. A reader who can pick a slower cadence has a choice other than the unsubscribe link.
What happens to paid subscribers if we change platform?
That is the part to test before you announce anything. Ask the old and new vendor how paying members, their billing relationship and their access move, and keep the old setup running until a test member can sign in on the new one.