Best email broadcast tools for creators growing a newsletter
A creator who is still building an audience should start on Kit. Its pricing page lists a free plan up to 10,000 subscribers with unlimited landing pages, forms and broadcasts, and the Creator plan, which adds sequences and Visual Automations for a lead-magnet welcome flow, is $33 a month at 1,000 subscribers on yearly billing. The tool matters less than where you will be when the price steps arrive, so the rest of this page prices five options at 1,000, 5,000 and 10,000 readers.
Growth is a funnel, and the tool affects only two of its stages
Newsletter growth for an independent creator has three parts: getting a stranger to a signup page, getting them to confirm, and getting them to read the second email. Software has little say over the first. It shapes the other two, because the signup page, the confirmation step and the welcome sequence all live in your email platform.
- The signup page. You want one page per source, such as a link in your bio, a page for each lead magnet and a form embedded in a post, so you can see which source sends readers who stay. This is why unlimited landing pages and forms on Kit's free plan matter more than a long template library.
- The confirmation and first email. Someone who signs up for a checklist expects the checklist within minutes. Check how each plan delivers a lead magnet: Kit's pricing page lists sequences and automations from Creator, not Free, so a free account may mean sending it by hand or from the form's confirmation page.
- The second to fifth email. The welcome sequence is where a reader decides whether to stay. Tools that cap you at a single workflow, as Flodesk's Lite plan does, force you to choose between a welcome series and any other automation until you upgrade.
Consent and list quality when you are chasing numbers
Growth pressure makes creators cut corners that cost them later. Google's sender guidelines say recipients should opt in, that confirming each address is good practice, and that opt-in boxes should not be checked by default; Yahoo's guidance names purchased lists and pre-checked boxes as things to avoid. A giveaway where entering means joining the newsletter produces readers who came for the prize, and their silence will pull down click rates and eventually inbox placement.
Two habits protect a growing list. First, say on the signup page how often you write; Yahoo's advice is to honour the frequency people expect, and a weekly newsletter that turns daily without warning is a classic way to generate unsubscribes and spam complaints. Second, track the number that matters, which is the share of new subscribers who click something in their first month, not the raw count of signups or opens. Open counts are an unreliable signal because mail clients can load images in advance, so judge by clicks and replies.
On the sending side, publish SPF, DKIM and DMARC for the domain you send from before you pass roughly 5,000 subscribers; Google's bulk-sender rules start at 5,000 messages a day to Gmail and require one-click unsubscribe, and a growing newsletter reaches that line sooner than it expects. See newsletter best practices and building a newsletter audience for the writing side.
Five tools priced at three sizes of audience
| Tool | Free tier | 1,000 | 5,000 | 10,000 | Limit that matters |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kit Creator (billed yearly) | Free to 10,000, no sequences | $33 | $75 | $116 | Branding stays on Free |
| beehiiv Lite | Free to 2,500, 1 publication | $0 | $109 monthly or $95 yearly | $139 monthly or $119 yearly | 1 team seat on Free |
| Flodesk Lite (monthly view) | No email sending | $25 | $52 | $72 | 1 workflow on Lite |
| MailerLite Comfort (billed monthly) | 250 subscribers, 2,500 emails | $19 | $49 | $89 | Emails capped at 10x the subscriber ceiling |
| Substack | Free to publish | $0 | $0 | $0 | 10% of paid revenue; sends from a substack.com address |
Kit: the plan with the longest free runway
You can build to 10,000 subscribers without paying for a broadcast, and the Pro plan, at $66 for 1,000 subscribers and $158 for 10,000, adds a newsletter referral system and Subscriber Signals once your audience is big enough to use them. The Creator price steps are $33, $75, $116 and $166 at 25,000. The catch is that free means no automation, so a lead-magnet funnel pushes most serious growth efforts onto Creator early.
beehiiv: free until 2,500, then steep
The free plan covers 2,500 subscribers, unlimited sends and one publication, which is a fair place to test an idea. Past that, Lite lists paid subscriptions, automations and audience polls, and the slider jumps to $109 monthly at 5,000. If you plan to charge for a paid tier later, beehiiv's page says it takes 0% of paid subscription revenue apart from Stripe's processing fee, which makes the subscription arithmetic simpler than a platform with a revenue share.
Flodesk: pay for sending, not for audience-building tools
Its free plan covers forms, landing pages and link-in-bio pages but, per its pricing page, no email sending or workflow automations. That makes it a decent way to collect signups before you decide, and Lite is $25 at 1,000 subscribers, $52 at 5,000 and $72 at 10,000 on monthly billing. Pro is $28 at 1,000 and adds unlimited workflows. The limit that matters is the single workflow on Lite.
MailerLite: low monthly-billed steps
Free covers 250 subscribers and 2,500 emails a month, which a creator passes within weeks. Comfort's monthly-billed $19, $49 and $89 sit below Kit Creator's yearly-billing $33, $75 and $116 at the same sizes, and the data centre is in the European Union per MailerLite's own page. The allowance is ten times your subscriber ceiling, so a daily sender at 1,000 subscribers runs into it where a weekly sender does not.
Substack: no monthly bill, but the list lives on its terms
You pay nothing until you charge readers, then 10% of subscription revenue plus card fees. Its help centre states that a custom domain costs a one-time $50, that emails still send from a substack.com address, and that a file with subscriber names cannot currently be exported. If growth is your goal and you may want to move later, that last line should weigh on you.
The yearly bill as the audience doubles
| Plan | A year at 5,000 | A year at 10,000 |
|---|---|---|
| Kit Creator, billed yearly | $75 x 12 = $900 | $116 x 12 = $1,392 |
| Flodesk Lite, annual billing | $48 x 12 = $576 | $66 x 12 = $792 |
| beehiiv Lite, yearly view | $95 x 12 = $1,140 | $119 x 12 = $1,428 |
| Flodesk Lite, monthly billing | $52 x 12 = $624 | $72 x 12 = $864 |
| MailerLite Comfort, monthly billing | $49 x 12 = $588 | $89 x 12 = $1,068 |
| beehiiv Lite, monthly view | $109 x 12 = $1,308 | $139 x 12 = $1,668 |
The rows are grouped by billing basis, because Kit's Creator rates are yearly-billing rates and MailerLite's are monthly. On the yearly basis at 10,000 subscribers, Flodesk Lite is $600 a year below Kit Creator ($1,392 minus $792) but has one workflow, while Kit's Free plan costs nothing if you can live without sequences. On the monthly basis at 10,000, Flodesk Lite ($864) is $204 below MailerLite Comfort ($1,068). beehiiv's monthly view at 10,000 is $1,668 a year, which is $240 more than its yearly view of $1,428.
Which to start on, and what to bring when you move
- Choose Kit if you want the longest free stretch and will add Creator when you launch a lead magnet.
- Choose beehiiv if a paid tier is on your roadmap and you want to start free up to 2,500.
- Choose Flodesk if you value design and expect one main automation.
- Choose MailerLite if you want a steady low price and a weekly cadence.
- Choose Substack if you want zero setup and accept its sending address.
Moving: export subscribers with signup date, source and tags, plus the unsubscribe list; confirm the source tool does export names. On the new tool, authenticate your sending domain with SPF, DKIM and DMARC, rebuild the signup forms and send one test welcome email to a Gmail and an Outlook address. Kit's pricing page lists free migrations. Compare similar pairings in beehiiv vs Substack and Kit alternatives, and see the blog hub for more.
FAQ
When should a creator start paying for an email tool?
When you need an automation you cannot do by hand, usually the welcome sequence that delivers a lead magnet. Before that, Kit's free plan up to 10,000 subscribers or beehiiv's up to 2,500 will carry a newsletter that is only sending broadcasts.
Does a bigger list always mean a higher bill?
On every paid plan above, yes: Kit, Flodesk, MailerLite and beehiiv all price by subscriber band. Removing people who never click is therefore a saving as well as a deliverability habit, though check each tool's definition of active before relying on that.
Should I use a lead magnet?
A useful free resource tied to your topic gives strangers a reason to join, and each one gets its own landing page so you can see which converts. Do not add people who downloaded to your newsletter unless the form said they would be subscribed.
Is it a problem to send from a free tool's shared branding?
For a hobby list, no. For a creator selling a service, the platform branding on Kit's free plan can look unpolished. Kit's pricing page lists branding removal from the Creator plan upward.